Home/ Tickers/ LLY
LLY PUBLIC EQUITY

LLY Stock Predictions, Graded Against Reality

10 tracked public figures made calls on LLY. Every pick graded against the S&P 500 over matching windows.

Total Calls
11
8 buy · 3 sell
Avg Buy Return
-8.1%
vs S&P +10.6%
Best Buy Call
+19.8%
David Solomon · Apr 2024
Figures Tracked
10
public figures with LLY calls

Is LLY a Buy or Sell?

Public buy calls on Eli Lilly have underperformed the S&P 500. On average, public BUY calls on Eli Lilly underperformed the S&P 500 by +18.7%.
Worse than indexBeat the index

Eli Lilly Analyst Ratings, Tracked & Graded

11 calls
Who Signal Date Return S&P Same Window Source
SS
 SELL Feb 24, 2026 ✓ Correct — source ↗
AB
 BUY Feb 27, 2026 -17.5% +4.2% source ↗
DK
 BUY Feb 07, 2026 -16.9% +3.1% source ↗
DK
 BUY Feb 24, 2026 -16.7% +4.0% source ↗
JC
 BUY Feb 25, 2026 -15.6% +3.2% source ↗
LC
 BUY Feb 25, 2026 -15.1% +2.7% source ↗
MC
 BUY Mar 16, 2026 -12.2% +6.9% source ↗
DS
 BUY Apr 25, 2024 +19.8% +42.0% source ↗
RW
 SELL Mar 12, 2026 ✓ Correct — source ↗
SL
 SELL May 12, 2025 ✓ Correct — source ↗
CC
 BUY Dec 25, 2024 +9.3% +18.9% source ↗

Who's Predicting Eli Lilly Stock?

10 figures
Chase Coleman
1 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -9.6%
Lori Calvasina
1 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -17.7%
Jim Cramer
1 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -18.8%
Mark Cuban
1 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -19.1%
David Kostin
2 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -20.3%
Ana Botin
1 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -21.7%
David Solomon
1 calls on LLY
Avg buy alpha: -22.3%
Ron Wyden
1 calls on LLY
Sell accuracy: 1/1
Savita Subramanian
1 calls on LLY
Sell accuracy: 1/1
Stephanie Link
1 calls on LLY
Sell accuracy: 1/1

Eli Lilly Stock Prediction Track Records

GotReceipts tracks public buy and sell signals for Eli Lilly (LLY) and measures outcomes over matched windows. For this ticker model, performance vs the S&P 500 is based on BUY/ADD calls only.

SELL/REDUCE calls are graded directionally and shown as Correct, Incorrect, or Pending. That way, you can quickly see whether following public buy calls added value versus simply holding the index.

Do LLY stock predictions beat the S&P 500?

No. Across 8 scored BUY/ADD calls, average return is -8.1% versus +10.6% for the S&P 500, for -18.7% alpha.

Who has the best track record predicting Eli Lilly?

Chase Coleman currently ranks #1 on LLY, with +9.3% average buy return versus +18.9% for the S&P 500 (-9.6% alpha) across 1 scored buy calls.

Is LLY overvalued or undervalued?

Public prediction track records currently lean cautious on LLY: buy calls have underperformed the index by +18.7% on average.

Should I follow analyst ratings on LLY?

Use analyst and public-figure calls as one input, not a standalone signal. GotReceipts shows historical outcomes versus the S&P 500 so you can judge signal quality before acting.